---
title: "Kill The Argument - Air Market"
description: "Your paper has passed the friendly reads and you are about to submit. This puts a fresh reviewer on it whose job is to reject it as forcefully as possible, then a second fresh reviewer who answers th…"
canonical: "https://airmarket.ai/app/kill-argument"
---

[Air Market](/) / [Research](/category/research) / Kill The Argument

Skill by [Yang Ruofeng](/@wanshuiyin)

# Kill The Argument

Hear the worst rejection your paper could get, before a reviewer writes it

## What this does

Your paper has passed the friendly reads and you are about to submit. This puts a fresh reviewer on it whose job is to reject it as forcefully as possible, then a second fresh reviewer who answers that attack point by point. What is left standing is the problem you still have. Reach for it when you want to know what is coming.

### Top 3 things it does for you

- Get the strongest case against my paper written out
- See which criticisms actually survive a defense
- Prepare for a hostile reviewer before I submit

## Information

**Kill The Argument at a glance**

|  |  |
| --- | --- |
| Kind | Skill |
| Publisher | [Yang Ruofeng](/@wanshuiyin) |
| Category | [Research](/category/research) |
| Works with | Agent Skills - an open standard supported by 40+ agents |
| Size | 22 KB |
| Licence | MIT |
| Repository | [wanshuiyin/auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep](https://github.com/wanshuiyin/auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep/tree/bab594e8216cbc2944c4184c4e4389e8f3fc1fb2/skills/skills-codex/kill-argument) |
| GitHub stars | 15,082 (as of Nov 2026) |

## Security report

**Verified.** AIR scanned this exact version of Kill The Argument and flagged nothing. AIR's verdict: **safe**.

**What Kill The Argument's check was run against**

|  |  |
| --- | --- |
| Commit | bab594e8216cbc2944c4184c4e4389e8f3fc1fb2 |
| Content hash | ec68737039c0b8bfae39f22ea7a1302a4fbc57885a06b840b8b331b0c6e15efd |
| Files read | [Browse the files at this exact commit](https://github.com/wanshuiyin/auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep/blob/bab594e8216cbc2944c4184c4e4389e8f3fc1fb2/skills/skills-codex/kill-argument/SKILL.md) |

A scan is named by the exact content it read, not by a version number. A different version is a different artifact, and nothing here applies to a version AIR has not scanned.

[Read the full security report for Kill The Argument](/security/kill-argument)

## About Kill The Argument

Standard review rounds are kind, or at least they are trying to help. The reviewer you actually fear is not, and you meet them after the deadline.

This runs two threads. A fresh reviewer builds the strongest rejection memo it can, held to a short length so the argument has to be its best rather than its longest. Then a second fresh reviewer takes that memo and defends the paper point by point, surfacing the critical issues that remain unresolved after the defense.

It is aimed at a theory paper that has already been through ordinary review, at the point where you want the hostile read rather than the helpful one.

## What's inside

- SKILL.md - instructions

## Questions

### Is Kill The Argument safe to install?

AIR scanned this exact version of Kill The Argument and flagged nothing. AIR's verdict: safe. The verdict is named by the content that was read, at commit bab594e8216c, so it cannot drift onto a version nobody scanned. The full report is at https://airmarket.ai/security/kill-argument.

### How do I install Kill The Argument?

Open https://airmarket.ai/app/kill-argument on Air Market and use the install action: Air Market hands Claude a prompt naming this exact skill, and Claude sets it up. Source, pinned to the exact commit this listing describes: https://github.com/wanshuiyin/auto-claude-code-research-in-sleep/tree/bab594e8216cbc2944c4184c4e4389e8f3fc1fb2/skills/skills-codex/kill-argument. Install from that link, not the branch.

## Related on Air Market

- [More Research listings](/category/research)
- [Everything by Yang Ruofeng](/@wanshuiyin)

---

Canonical URL: <https://airmarket.ai/app/kill-argument>